Saturday, March 4, 2023

Covid, Children and Education – What’s the real cost?

 



 

Life at the height of the pandemic was difficult for everyone due to the high number of things – and people – we had to sacrifice in order to follow the ever-changing rules. Cast your mind back to daily updates, graphs showing death tolls and dire warnings to stay away from one another. In the midst of that chaos were young children who had recently started school, but were then suddenly forced to stay away for months at a time in lockdown. Children of all ages struggled, and as they returned, there were gaps in learning across the board. Recovery curriculums were in place, informal assessments to see where the children were at, with mathematics being the most affected subject.

Though, it’s the other side of the coin that I have found to be the most worrying factor. The global director of education, Jaime Saavedra, called it “the largest simultaneous shock to all education systems in our lifetime.”

The most critical brain development is experienced between the ages of 0-5 years. During this crucial time, the brain develops more than at any period in a person’s life. The quality of education and early experiences are paramount as they greatly shape the child’s ability to learn and succeed for a lifetime, and this particular set of children were apart from friends and the school routine they had settled into, having a noticeable effect. Teachers have commented that the impact of the pandemic on reception pupils had been larger than anticipated and are still being felt by pupils, staff, and leaders to this day.

There has been a vast increase in pupils with poor mental health and well-being; a surge in referrals being made to outside agencies, all now with longer waiting lists. Children have struggled with peer interaction, poorer behaviours, school readiness and attitude to learning. The pandemic has hindered opportunities for children’s language and communication development. Even physical fitness has suffered, as children missed PE and general physical activity, some returning to school unfit, more overweight and lacking in stamina and resilience.

There was much anxiety around catching Covid and some children sadly being affected by grief after the deaths of people close to them. An After School Club employee painted a bleak picture indeed of the bubble system, with toys being hid from sight and all they could have was a sealed pack of pencil crayons and some colouring sheets. Bouncy, fidgety reception children spread two metres apart, told not to touch anything and remain seated at all times. It’s frankly unsurprising that such draconian rules set upon four-year-olds left them confused and distressed. I’m not playing a blame game here. School staff were merely following the protocol, but at what cost to our young children overall?

The reception children barely had any reception time, missing vital milestones of social and emotional development. They were not prepared to begin Y1, which is less play and more structured lesson work. All of the year groups seemed younger than their predecessors with acting out and immature behaviour, because they hadn’t had the opportunity for growth and a natural transition.

In turn, the year group moving up to take their reception places were in the same predicament, as they too experienced interrupted nursery provision. These children were expected to be ready for these changes. But they were not, because how could they be?

What has been thoroughly sad to see is that the SEND children, and the disadvantaged, have clearly suffered the most. They need a lot of extra support on a daily basis, and they had a long and lonely period without the structures in place that they have in their schools. When remote learning was born, it was a tricky time for both pupils and parents. The gap grew wider as disadvantaged students struggled to flourish without devices and technology which families simply could not afford. Children with learning barriers no longer had that expert 1:1 supporting advantage. It had gone. Parents tried their best, but we’re not all professional educators.

I spoke with both school staff and parents as I was writing this story, and their struggles were real and a universal truth across the board. Staff have received extra training since, with mental health first aid and how to appropriately handle a child in crisis at the top of the bill. They are learning about pupils who have experienced trauma, because they need to. Personally, I think it’s a great and positive step forward, but it also highlights the true and, sometimes, lasting effects that the Covid-19 pandemic has really had on these children, aside from being behind in phonics and mathematics, there has been a deeper cost, a sadder one.

Primary School Teacher: “It’s a travesty really. The stresses of that time were felt by those developing minds.”

A father: “My daughter was in primary school when Covid happened, and it impacted her. It was a very difficult time for me and my family. She was upset, reserved, and scared. I was very clueless and helpless.”

School Support Worker: “The constant mixed messages have confused the younger children. Be kind and share / don’t share. Don’t touch. Quick, let’s sanitise your hands. Some children returned self-entitled after lockdown, quite forgetting the rules, patience, and manners.”

Reception teacher: “Sadly, there is a stigma attached to trauma, and parents are reluctant to admit their child is feeling that, but many are after Covid.”

As I am writing this article, Matt Hancock’s WhatsApp messages have recently been leaked and everything Covid is back hanging heavily in the air once again, with questions being asked with a fresh scrutiny. I’ve been reading through the disagreements between ministers regarding the subject of the school closures at the time. Schools opened for one mere pointlessly distracting day because they couldn’t make their minds up, couldn’t stop dithering and ending up making a ridiculous U-turn. To say that children, school staff and parents have ben messed around is a huge understatement. As ministers quibbled and verbally threw teachers under the bus, more and more children were lost and dazed in a system that couldn’t be there for them.

The stress and anxiety placed upon the teaching profession has been absolutely overwhelming. The sneering comments made by Matt Hancock and Gavin Williamson are reprehensible and degrading. Who has been there to pick up the pieces for our suffering children? As teachers take further strike action in the coming weeks, I hope people remember the true sacrifices they have made.




 

 

 

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment